Green travel vs. carbon offsetting: where do we draw the line?
Read more about: carbon, carbon footprint, carbon offsets, flights, responsible tourism, responsibletravel.com, Terrapass
Responsibletravel.com, popular travel site centered around responsible leisure travel and vacations, has announced today that it plans to remove the ability for its customers to offset their carbon emissions via its website.
For a good part of the last decade, carbon offsetting has been a large player in consumer-based, green travel initiatives. Companies like Carbonfund and terrapass have become very successful by allowing travelers and organizations that are looking for a “green edge” to offset their carbon rations for things like flights, hotel stays, rental cars and more.
However, this week, popular sustainably-minded travel portal responsibletravel.com has taken a formal stand against carbon offsetting, calling the very idea of offsets “dangerously distracting.”
The website was one of the very first travel organizations to actually introduce carbon offsetting to the masses in early 2002. Now, it is one of the first to speak out against them – citing the travel industry’s need to reduce rather than offset carbon emissions.
“We have thought long and hard about how we can continue to offer our customers the leading advice they expect from a responsible tourism business when it comes to the fast growing impact of flying on the environment,” said Justin Francis, MD, responsibletravel.com. “We believe that the travel industry’s priority must be to reduce carbon emissions, rather than to offset.”
In a recent report by Friends of the Earth, carbon offsetting was deemed a “dangerous distraction” – a deterrent for tourists from the need to actually reduce their carbon footprint, creating a sort of guilt-free illusion of environmentally friendly travel.
Francis agrees with this report, and continues to say that “Too often offsets are being used by the tourism industry in developed countries to justify growth plans on the basis that money will be donated to projects in developing countries. Global reduction targets will not be met this way.”
In its place, responsibletravel.com is working with Friends of the Earth to put in place a clear, alternativeset of advice and guidelines to enable travelers to “carbon cautious.” for travellers offering
“Ultimately we need to reduce our carbon emissions,” continued Francis. “We can do this by flying less – travelling by train or taking holidays closer to home for example, and by making carbon reductions in other areas of our lifestyles too, alongside travel.
“There is no hiding the fact that tourists will continue to want to visit destinations requiring a flight, and that tourism contributes to livelihoods, local economic development and the conservation of the world’s cultural and natural heritage. We will continue to offer a more responsible choice of overseas holiday so that when tourists do fly they can ‘make their holiday count’ by choosing a more responsible holiday.”
Responsibletravel.com has also teamed up with leading responsible tourism academic Professor Harold Goodwin, Director International Center for Responsible Tourism on his FlySmart Campaign for Responsible Aviation: www.flysmart.org . The campaign supports a Carbon Friendly Flight Search functionality, enabling travelers to search and compare the cheapest and most environmentally friendly fares available around the world.
For more information visit www.flysmart.org and www.responsibletravel.com/carboncaution.
More like this:
About the Author
Joe is a full time web designer, developer and marketing guy working in the online travel technology marketplace. TerraCurve.com is his personal project - an avenue of creativity that combines his beliefs in social responsibility with both professional and personal experience.
See more contributions (252 so far) from Joe Ascanio.
Network on LinkedIn

Going green and wild in China with a new carbon offset option
Choose to fly green with Air Canada
How green is the World Cup?
Responsible travel goes mobile with a new iPhone App
Canadian hotels have the right idea: Green is the way to go
Giant sea turtles swimming up to safe haven in Panama
San Francisco welcomes new shark exhibit in name of conservation
Standing together for a better world
Travel inspiration 2.0
Why stronger regulations are crucial to combating climate change 


Pingback by Tweets that mention Green travel vs. carbon offsetting: where do we draw the line? : TerraCurve.com: Go beyond green. | Responsible travel news, places, people and events. -- Topsy.com on October 16th, 2009:
[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Kat Brimacombe, Green Travel News. Green Travel News said: #GTFeeds : Green travel vs. carbon offsetting: where do we draw the line?- For a good part of the last decade, carb… http://bit.ly/2kJQp [...]
Pingback by e « Green Girl meets All American Boy on October 18th, 2009:
[...] while this all seems nice and dandy, carbon offsets are quite controversial. Where is your money going? Do carbon offsets really help the environment? Does this create [...]
Pingback by See the world, Save the world « Green Girl meets All American Boy on October 18th, 2009:
[...] while this all seems nice and dandy, carbon offsets are quite controversial. Where is your money going? Do carbon offsets really help the environment? Does this create [...]
Comment by Janice on October 19th, 2009:
What do you think about electric travel vans for a travel to woods or any place wouldn't it be much more safer for the environment to use such kind of travel vans?
Comment by Janice on October 19th, 2009:
What do you think about electric travel vans for a travel to woods or any place wouldn't it be much more safer for the environment to use such kind of travel vans?